"Suppose my neighbor's home catches fire, and I have a
length of garden hose four or five hundred feet away. If he can take my
garden hose and connect it up with his hydrant, I may help him to put out
his fire...I don't say to him before that operation, "Neighbor, my
garden hose cost me $15; you have to pay me $15 for it."... I don't
want $15--I want my garden hose back after the fire is over. "
Franklin Roosevelt's Press Conference on Lend Lease
March 11 , 1941
PRESIDENT: At quarter to four or ten minutes to four, the [Lend-Lease] Bill
[H. R. 1776] was duly signed in the presence of the press photographers and
the picture people; and immediately thereafter -- after they left the room-
the second step happened. After talking the thing over with the Army and
Navy authorities, the first list of material was approved -- Army and Navy
material which will go, the greater part of it, to Britain; a portion of it
will go to the Greeks. The items, of course, involved must of necessity and
fairness be kept secret until such time that the disclosure of their
military identity will not be of benefit to anybody else.
meeting this morning on that line, I told the Senate and House members of
the Committee- we talked it over and I made the suggestion that they
appoint from the two Appropriations Committees a small subcommittee that
would feel entirely free to come down here at any time and be kept in
complete and constant touch with everything that is being done under Bill
course, there is nothing that could not be disclosed except some of these
things which probably we should defer announcing- the type of material or
amounts involved -- for purely military reasons for a reasonably short
time. This particular list of items relates both to the Army and Navy. It
is not a very large amount. I only have at the present time the figures
showing the total original cost, because you will understand that that does
not necessarily mean the billing price for the reason that a great many of
these articles are out of date or surplus and haven't got the same monetary
value that they had when they were manufactured a good many years ago.
I -- well, you saw the gentlemen when they went out; they told you about
the letter tomorrow which will be the usual -- I have forgotten whether it
is deficiency or supplemental estimate letter -- to the Speaker. It is not
a message to the Congress, because this is an appropriation bill and it
goes in in the form of a deficiency or supplemental estimate to the
Speaker, and, under the rules of the House, it is referred by him to the
Appropriations Committee; and then they start hearings, I think, the day
after. My letter will go up at noon tomorrow, and they will start the
hearings on Thursday; so there is no waste of time in this procedure.
President, you said you had a total of the value; are you going to tell us
what that is?
President, you called these supplemental or deficiency..
PRESIDENT: (interposing) I don't know whether they call it deficiency or
Usually supplemental is for the current year; is this for the current year?
Q. What I
am getting at, will there be another one for next year?
PRESIDENT: I don't know. You better ask them on the Hill what they want to
call it; really, it is an appropriation bill under H. R. 1776.
President, you have indicated that this list of stuff is current material,
surplus, et cetera.
haven't read the bill lately; that bill mentioned a certain amount.
PRESIDENT: Up to a billion, three hundred million; the amount arrived at --
the value of this stuff -- will come out of that billion, three hundred
Q. I was
going to ask you further, sir, if you will permit me, if there have been
any terms or any dicker; have you made a deal with these people?
that be made public at any time you do so?
PRESIDENT: As soon as it is proper. Of course the Congressional people will
know about it, but it won't be made public until the items themselves are
made public. You couldn't do any figuring on dollars and cents unless you
knew what the items were.
President, is this a lending or a leasing procedure?
THE PRESIDENT: I give it up; I'm not interested.
President, could you tell us when the proposed aid to China may be
PRESIDENT: The what?
for China; I heard you mention Britain and Greece.
PRESIDENT: That's all I've done today! (Laughter)
there be aid to China?
PRESIDENT: Oh, I guess so.
it depend, sir, on the report that Lauchlin Currie makes to you?
PRESIDENT: That might have something to do with it; I wouldn't say it would
depend on it.
President, will some of this be out of the 1942 budget?
PRESIDENT: There is not much we can talk about yet because it is still in
the process of working out on the Hill as to whether certain types of
things taken out by anticipation, things already ordered but not yet
delivered, already appropriated for and ordered and which would fall into
the one billion-three-hundred-million-dollar category -- as to whether they
should be deducted, or any portion of them, from the seven-billion-dollar
appropriation or not. That is a thing that is really a legislative matter
and we hadn't worked it out this morning. There are too many categories of
things in there to make an over-all statement; some might and some might
not. . . .
Q. Is it
proper for you to say whether any of this equipment is now on the way?
PRESIDENT: Oh, no, none of it is on the way -- at least it wasn't until
five minutes to four, because I didn't approve it until then. We work fast,
but there are limitations! (Laughter)
Our Document List