His Excellency Harold B. Butler -3 August 5, 1942.
case in logic, gets backing from an admirable national misconception.
For the average American still believes that America is invincible
on the home rounds. That is our danger as well as America
Nothing effective has been done to meet this situation. I have
no doubt that immense industry and scholarship is being poured
into your propaganda machine. But the machine is whirling in
thin air. In little ways, it may palliate the dancers. But it
cannot effect a cure.
For this is not a problem in propaganda. The job is not to
expound Britain to America. It is definitely more fundamental
than that. The job is not to tinker up the old situation. It
is to build a new one. It is to change the present ill-designed
relatively unworkable scheme of British American partnership
into absolute British American unity. It is to convince the common
man of America that there will not be victory unless America
and the British Empire are one.
In the philosophy of the old order, America and Britain were
designed to be competitors and opponents. War in itself cannot
wholly overcome that fact. It will take a revolutionary act to
unite the English-speaking people. It will take a new purpose,
inspiration, and leadership. It will take a new order of dem
This problem in British American unity arose when war began.
For then it was plain to thinking men that world fascism was
on the march against world democracy; that nothing but the maximum
efficiency of English-speaking democracy was good enough to win;
that maximum efficiency depended upon the absolute unity of the
English-speaking people;